• 4 Posts
  • 113 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 7th, 2023

help-circle





  • I don’t know about your personal situation, and it may be different for whatever you are suffering with, however the part you quoted is true for a lot of cases.

    Having just looked after my wife through a period of ~3 years really severe depression I’ve seen it first hand, it completely changed her personality and outlook and she was saying all kinds of stuff she’s quite embarrassed by now. She genuinely couldn’t think straight at all or see any way out, and in that moment if offered the choice to die she might have taken it (a fact she is quite scared by now, having mostly recovered).

    Similar story with my brother, who has bipolar… when he’s manic he has an absolute inability to hold a train of thoughts together for longer than 30 seconds. When he’s depressed it’s absolutely awful. He’s now stable and enjoying his life.

    I’m not arguing that this shouldn’t be an option for some very extreme chronic conditions, but it’s obviously complicated.











  • Yeah I don’t disagree with what you’re saying, we don’t put fresh grads on jobs without adequate supervision on the design side either. On both sides of the “fence” you need the experience to produce a good product; the two jobs are different and should be complimentary.

    The schemes I have worked on that have been the most successful have had the designer and contractor working together closely from an early stage to produce something that works well, drawing on the past experience of both to anticipate potential issues and design them out.

    Personally it took me about 6 years before I felt I was good at design. Experience really does count.




  • That ship was about 100,000t.

    There’s a fairly crude equation in the American bridge engineering standard that relates impact load to the mass of a ship, which is:

    P =√(DWT) ±50%

    Where DWT is the deadweight tonnage, and P is the impact load in meganewtons.

    So in this case P=315MN ±50% which is 315000kN or 31500 tonnes of force…

    For comparison, I’m working on a project where we’re going to build a new concrete bridge on the ground next to where it needs to go (under a railway) then wait until we have a planned week with no trains running and push it into position using jacks. That bridge is a 60m long 20m wide 8m high concrete box with 1m thick walls and top and bottom slabs, and we think we will need about 30MN to install it (one tenth of the impact load from that ship).

    So yeah… that’s quite a hit.